| |

What to Eat in Saugatuck, Michigan: The Spots We Keep Going Back To

We’ve done Saugatuck twice now: a fall weekend in October 2023 for Hannah’s birthday (pups included) and a summer weekend in June 2026 with Finley. Our favorite list to make. Every time we go, we eat more and more.

One of the most beautiful things is this town freezes in time. Though we were 3 years later, not much had changed.

So here it is: what to eat in Saugatuck, from a two-mom family who has done the patio breakfasts, the cinnamon roll and the ice cream stands with a toddler in tow. A few of these are in Douglas, Saugatuck’s sister town right across the lake. 🤍

Planning the whole trip? Here’s our summer weekend in Saugatuck itinerary and our fall weekend in Saugatuck.

Where We Eat in Saugatuck, at a Glance

All in one place, for your notes app:

  • Uncommon Coffee Roasters, 127 Hoffman St: our coffee stop every trip, and very LGBTQ+ friendly.
  • Pennyroyal Cafe & Provisions, 3319 Blue Star Hwy: brunch on the patio and a pastry window, just outside downtown.
  • Pumpernickel’s, 202 Butler St: all day food downtown, and THE cinnamon roll.
  • Ida Red’s Cottage, 645 Water St: a breakfast and lunch staple since 1986.
  • Lady Bird, 149 Griffith St: brunch, dinner and the espresso martini.
  • The Butler, 40 Butler St: lunch on the patio right on the water.
  • Marker 14, 340 Water St: the new waterfront spot that opened in 2026.
  • Douglas Root Beer Barrel, 501 W Center St, Douglas: root beer floats since 1952.
  • Coast 236, 236 Culver St: the nice dinner. Save it for a special night.
  • Dairy Dayz, 6471 Blue Star Hwy: a roadside stand with soft serve and flurries.
  • Kilwins, 152 Butler St: the ice cream stop downtown.

Things to Note Before You Eat Your Way Through Saugatuck

Things to Note:

  • Check the day before you go. Pennyroyal is closed Tuesdays, Lady Bird is closed Mondays, Coast 236 is closed Monday and Tuesday, and Marker 14 is only open Thursday through Sunday.
  • A lot of Saugatuck is seasonal. The Root Beer Barrel and Dairy Dayz close for the winter, and Ida Red’s cuts back to fewer days, so call before you drive over in the off season.
  • No high chairs at Pennyroyal. Bring a travel seat or plan on lap time.
  • Book dinner ahead. Coast 236 and Lady Bird both take reservations, and so does Pennyroyal for dinner.
  • Park once and walk. Everything downtown is right there. Pennyroyal, Dairy Dayz and the Root Beer Barrel are the ones you’ll want the car for.

Where to Stay in Saugatuck

We’ve stayed a few different ways in Saugatuck: a vacation rental across the street from Main Street, the Best Western, and our favorite, the Wickwood Inn. It has the cute homey vibe to it (and it’s in town). Here’s the map plus our top 3.

In a Rush? Here Are Our Top 3 Hotels in Saugatuck

⭐️⭐️⭐️ Wickwood Inn: Our favorite. A cozy inn on Butler Street right in town, so you can walk to dinner and back. Click here for rates & availability

⭐️⭐️ A vacation rental near Main Street: On our fall trip we stayed in a rental right across the street from Main Street. Cross the road, go down the stairs and you’re in town. Click here for rates & availability

⭐️ Best Western Plaza Hotel Saugatuck: Where we stayed in June. It’s on Blue Star Highway a short drive from downtown, right down the road from Pennyroyal, with an indoor pool and free breakfast. Click here for rates & availability

These are affiliate links. If you book through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.


Coffee and Breakfast in Saugatuck

Uncommon Coffee Roasters

We always stop and pick up roasting beans and grab a fun crafted coffee while walking through town. It’s always busy, but there is a reason. It’s a little coffee shop on Hoffman Street, very LGBTQ+ friendly, with their own beans lined up on the shelves. We’ve been in the fall and in the summer, and it’s the first stop both times. You can see Hannah’s midday coffee and her midday heat we didn’t expect.

  • Address: 127 Hoffman St, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 857-3333
  • Hours: 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. Sunday through Thursday, until 6 p.m. Friday and Saturday
  • Website: uncommoncoffeeroasters.com
An iced coffee held up in front of the Uncommon Coffee Roasters sign on Hoffman Street
The Pennyroyal Cafe and Provisions sign on Blue Star Highway in Saugatuck

Pennyroyal Cafe & Provisions

We would give them 150 stars out of 5 if we could. Pennyroyal is just outside downtown on Blue Star Highway, with a patio out back in the trees and a little pastry window when you just want to grab and go. On our fall trip it was pouring, so we drove over for pancakes, and we grabbed coffees at the window on our way out of town. In June we ate on the patio with Finley on a lap.

  • Address: 3319 Blue Star Hwy, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 455-5133
  • Hours: 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. Thursday through Sunday, 8 a.m. to 3 p.m. Monday and Wednesday, closed Tuesday
  • Good to know: brunch until 4 p.m., dinner 5 to 9 p.m. with reservations on their site
  • Website: pennyroyalprovisions.com

Pennyroyal has a walkup ordering station and the Lattee and ANY baked good is our ritual stop if we awaken before 8 am. It’s a reward to get up early. The breakfast is so good, and in the fall when we went they had so much amazing seasonal items, but sitting inside during a dreary fall day is magical in this building.

Pumpernickel’s

All day food and fun, right on Butler Street. Their cinnamon roll changed our life! It comes out piled with icing and it’s big enough to share, and Finley could not take his eyes off it. We got eggs and bacon too, but let’s be honest, we came for the roll.

  • Address: 202 Butler St, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 455-5299
  • Hours: 9 a.m. to 9 p.m., except Wednesday and Sunday when they close at 3 p.m.
  • Website: pumpernickelssaugatuck.com
The dining room at Pumpernickel's on Butler Street in downtown Saugatuck

Ida Red’s Cottage

Since 1986, this has been a breakfast and lunch staple. You can dine inside or outside and feel like you are sitting at your grandma’s table for a home cooked meal.

  • Address: 645 Water St, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 455-9834
  • Hours: 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. Thursday through Sunday in season, fewer days in winter
  • Website: saugatuck.com

Lady Bird

This is going to be your brunch and dinner plans for something that feels at home and fancy at the same time. Trust me when I tell you to try the espresso martini. It’s on Griffith Street downtown, with a little inn upstairs.

  • Address: 149 Griffith St, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 354-2038
  • Brunch: 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. Tuesday through Friday, 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Saturday and Sunday
  • Dinner: every night but Monday, with reservations on their site
  • Website: ladybirdsaugatuck.com

Lunch in Saugatuck

Walking up to The Butler restaurant on Butler Street in Saugatuck with a toddler

The Butler

The Butler has been around since 1961, right on the channel by the boats. We had an early dinner there on Hannah’s birthday weekend in 2023, and in June we did exactly what we told you to do in our summer itinerary: lunch at the Butler on the patio before heading out. Finley got his own chair and his bunny got the table.

  • Address: 40 Butler St, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 857-3501
  • Hours: 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Monday through Thursday, until 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday, until 8 p.m. Sunday
  • Website: butlerrestaurant.com

The Butler is on the water, so you get the views whether on the patio or in the building. Their fries are a potato log style that I was obsessed with.

Marker 14

Marker 14 is the new kid on the water. It opened in May 2026 in the old Mermaid building on Water Street, and we walked in for lunch that June. We shared the warm pepperjack dip loaded with jalapeños, the Thai chicken meatballs with lettuce wraps and the caprese, and Finley supervised.

  • Address: 340 Water St, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 230-2295
  • Hours: 11 a.m. to 8:30 p.m. Thursday through Sunday
  • Website: marker14.com
The Marker 14 sign with its red buoy on Water Street in Saugatuck

We dropped into Marker14 before our RetroBoat right, because they are basically next door. We were there midday so it was a steady group of people, but we ate all appetizers and had no regret!

The giant wooden root beer barrel stand in Douglas, Michigan

Douglas Root Beer Barrel

This historical root beer stand is the perfect stop going to and from the beach for your snacks, ice cream, and of course your root beer float! It’s a giant wooden barrel in Douglas that’s been pouring since 1952, and it’s a family favorite. We got our float in June before 11 in the morning. No shame in it okay? THIS IS YOUR #1 MUST. It’s historical and has the best Rootbeer float I ever had.

  • Address: 501 W Center St, Douglas
  • Season: summer only, and they’re closed until summer 2027, so check their page before you go
  • Website: douglasbarrel.com

Dinner in Saugatuck

Coast 236

Coast 236 is the nice dinner in town. Super nice, so save it for a special dinner. We did: it was Hannah’s birthday weekend in October 2023. It’s a little more formal, and the corn risotto does not disappoint. Then we got two desserts, because birthday.

  • Address: 236 Culver St, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 455-5112
  • Hours: dinner 5 to 10 p.m. Wednesday through Saturday, 5 to 9 p.m. Sunday, closed Monday and Tuesday
  • Reservations: OpenTable, through their site
  • Website: coast236.com
Smiling at the table before a birthday dinner at Coast 236 in Saugatuck

We had Hannah’s birthday dinner here and it did not disappoint. The risotto was life changing, especially as a girl that loves corn.

Want another dinner option? Lady Bird and Pennyroyal both do dinner too (more on those up in breakfast).


Ice Cream in Saugatuck

Toddler getting a bite of soft serve at the Dairy Dayz pick up window near Saugatuck

Dairy Dayz

Dairy Dayz is a little walk up ice cream stand just outside town on Blue Star Highway, and we stopped on a June evening after our retro boat ride. Hand dipped Country Dairy ice cream, soft serve, flurries and a menu board you’ll stand in front of way too long. Finley got bites of soft serve and sips from our cup.

  • Address: 6471 Blue Star Hwy, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 857-7524
  • Season: summer, closed for the season right now
  • Website: saugatuck.com

Kilwins

Kilwins is the ice cream stop downtown on Butler Street. It’s the one from our summer itinerary: early dinner, a sunset cruise, then ice cream and a walk around downtown with the lights on.

  • Address: 152 Butler St, Saugatuck
  • Phone: (269) 455-5013
  • Website: kilwins.com

Top Spots We Haven’t Tried Yet

These are next on our list for Saugatuck and Douglas. Tell me if you’ve been!

  • Everyday People Cafe, 11 Center St, Douglas: dinner Thursday through Monday, 5 to 9 p.m.
  • Saugatuck Brewing Company, 2948 Blue Star Hwy, Douglas: the brewery’s Douglas pub, lunch and dinner every day from noon to 8, and LGBTQ+ friendly.

Saugatuck, We’ll Be Back (Hungry)

Coffee on Hoffman Street, a cinnamon roll big enough to share, a root beer float before lunch and a patio on the water. That’s what to eat in Saugatuck, and we’d eat it all again.

Planning more? Here’s our summer weekend in Saugatuck itinerary and our fall weekend in Saugatuck.

Tell me if you go! Come say hi on Instagram and tell me your favorite bite in Saugatuck. 🤍

Pin this post for your Saugatuck trip!

Heads up: this post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read our full disclosure.


Discover more from It's the Sterlings

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

More Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *